A Systematic Review of the Existing Literature to Evaluate What is Already Known of the Participatory Irrigation Management
SSnigdha Giri
SSubhra Chattopadhyay
128 Views
Submitted
2024/08/01
First Online
2025/05/16
doi
10.18805/ag.R-2754
Cite article - Snigdha Giri, Subhra Chattopadhyay. (2025). A Systematic Review of the Existing Literature to Evaluate What is Already Known of the Participatory Irrigation Management. Agricultural Reviews. 47(3): 426–432. doi: 10.18805/ag.R-2754
Abstract
The Participatory irrigation Management (PIM) introduced in the 1970s provided for a decentralised and citizenry based irrigation with multi-actor involvement. Though welcomed and applied globally with great enthusiasm, the true impact of PIM still remains obscure. This work tries to demystify this obscurity to identify the nature of evidence and impact as reported by the works on PIM since 1980s. A systematic review of 51 works has been made from Asia, Africa and the Americas to understand both the spatial and temporal pattern of the works. The study finds the works were spatially biased towards Asia and Africa and the major part of the review was based in the decade 2010-2020. The quality of data of the reporting works was mainly based on secondary evidences and on smaller sample sizes. The study found the failure of the government as the major reason backing the rise of PIM and various internal and external factors were affecting its functioning. About 60% of the studies have used the water related outcomes for impact analysis. The study finds that the impact as reported by the papers has been mixed with 30% of the total works claiming the outcome to be a positive one while 45% reporting it as negative or negligible. The study hints at the weakness of the preceding works in attaining consensus on the methods and impacts of PIM. The works also fail to bring out the ‘human’ part of the practice where the socio-psychological aspects of the actors have remained grossly underrated and unreported.
References
Aarnoudse, E., Closas, A. and Lefore, N. (2018) Water user associations: A review of approaches and alternative management options for Sub-Saharan Africa. Colombo, Sri Lanka: Inter- national Water Management Institute (IWMI Working Paper 180). 77. https://doi.org/10.5337/2018.210 Ahmed, B., Pham, D.H., Ashfaq, M., Memon, A.J., Bano, R., Dahri, Z., Mustafa, N.R., Baig, A.I. and Naseer, R.A.M. (2020). Impact of Institutional Features on the Overall Performance Assessment of Participatory Irrigation Management: Farmer’s Response from Pakistan. Water. 12: 497. https://doi.org/10.3390/ w12020497 Armanios, E.D. (2010) Sustainable Development as a Community of Practice: Insights from rural water projects in Egypt. Sustainable Development . 20: 42-57. Wiley Online Library. https://doi.org/10.1002/sd.463 Banki, I.S. (1981). Dictionary of Administration and Management. System Research Institute, Los Angeles, California. USA, 2. Cambaza, C., Hoogesteger, J. and Veldwisch, J.G. (2020). Irrigation management transfer in sub-Saharan Africa: an analysis of policy implications across scales. Water International. 45(1): 3-19. https://doi.org/10.1080/02508060. (2019). 1702310 Chandrasekaran, C., Umashankar, P., Duraiswaminathan, V. and Jayakumar, R. (2002) Water Users Association for sustainable water management: Experiences from the irrigation sector, Tamil Nadu, India. New Delhi, UNESCO. Facon, T. (2002). Improving the Irrigation Service to Farmers: A Key Issue in Participatory Irrigation Management. Food and Agricultural Organisation of the United Nations. Fan, Y., Park, S. and Nan, Z. (2018). Participatory water management and adoption of micro-irrigation systems: Smallholder farmers in arid north-western China. International Journal of Water Resources Development. 34(3): 434-452. http://.doi.org/ 10.1080/07900627.2017.1400424 Gandhi, P.V. and Namboodiri, V.N. (2008). Participatory Irrigation Management in India: An Evaluation of the Performance in Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat and Maharashtra.Centre for Mangement in Agriculture, Indian Institute of Management, Ahmedabad. Geijer, J.C.M.A., Svendsen, M. and Vermillion, D.L. (1996). Transferring Irrigation Management Responsibility in Asia: Results of a Workshop. Short Report Series on Locally Managed Irrigation No.13. International Irrigation Management Institute, Colombo. Ghosh, S., Singh, R., Kundu, K.D. and Kumar, A. (2008). Farmer’s Participation In Irrigation Management. Journal of Rural Development. 7(2): 231-244. Groenfeldt, D. and Sun, P. (1997). The Concept of Participatory Irrigation Management. World Bank, Washington D.C. (USA), Economic Development Institute. pp 45-47. Hussain, S., Khan, M. M., Shoaib, M., Raza, A., Shah, R.A.S., Khan, A.T. and Khan, S. (2021). Performance evaluation of participatory irrigation management system as an alternative to state- managed irrigation system. Irrigation and Drainage. 70(1): 150-168. http://doi.org/10.1002/ird.2515. Jadeja, M.R. and Parmar, S.J. (2017). Quintessential paradigm of participatory irrigation management in Gujarat. International Journal of Business and General Management. 6(4). Joy, M.M.J., Mitra, B. and RoySingha, A.K. (2021). Growth and yield performance of wheat genotypes under restricted irrigation in eastern sub-himalayan plains. Indian Journal of Agricultural Research . 55(4): 505-508. doi: 10.18805/IJARe.A-5545. Kono, S., Ounvichit, T., Ishii, A. and Satoh, M. (2012) Participatory system for water management in the toyogawa irrigation project, Japan. Paddy Water Environ. 10: 75-81. https://doi.org/ 10.1007/s10333-011-0266-2 Kulkarni, S.A. and Tyagi, A.C. (2012). Participatory irrigation management: understanding the role of cooperative culture. International Commission on Irrigation and Drainage. pp 1-8. Kumar, A.K., Devi, U.M., Reddy, M.D., Mahalaxmi, D.V. and Bhavani, O. (2023). Assesment of crop water productivity in an intensively cultivated watershed of peninsular India. Indian Journal of Agricultural Research. 57(4): 496-499. doi:10.18805/ IJARe.A-5612 . Mancosu, N., Synder, L.R., Kyriakakis, G. and Spano, D. (2015). Water scarcity and future challenges for food production. Water. 7(3): 975-992. http://doi.org/10.03390/w7030975. Meinzen-Dick, R. (1997). Farmer participation in irrigation- 20 years of experience and lessons for the future. Irrigation and Drainage System . 11: 103-118. Miao, S., Heijman, W., Zhu, X. and Lu, Q. (2015). Social capital influences farmer participation in collective irrigation management in Shaanxi province, China. China Agricultural Economic Review. 7(3): 448-466. http://doi.org/10.1108/CAER-05- 2014-0044. Mitra, A.K. (1992). Joint management of irrigation systems in India: relevance of japanese experience. Economic and Political Weekly. Mungsunti, A., Parton, A.K. (2017). Estimating the economic and environmental benefits of a traditional communal water irrigation system: The case of muang fai in Northern Thailand. Agricultural Water Management . 179: 366-377. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agwat.2016.05.036. Nyam, S.Y., Kotir, H. J., Jordaan, J.A., Ogundeji, A.A. and Turton, R.A. (2020). Drivers of change in sustainable water management and agricultural development in South Africa: A participatory approach. Sustainable Water Resources Management. 6(62): 1-20. https://doi.org./10.1007/s40899-020-00420-9 Pék, É., Fert o, I., Alobid, M. (2019). Evaluating the Effect of Farmers’ Participation in Irrigation Management on Farm Productivity and Profitability in the Mubuku Irrigation Scheme, Uganda. Water . (11): 2413. https://doi.org10.3390/w11112413 Poddar, R., Qurashi, E.M. and Syme, G. (2011). Comparing irrigation management reforms in Australia and India- A Special reference to participatory irrigation management. Irrigation and drainage. 60(2): 139-150. http://doi.org/10.1002/ird.551 Rede, D,.G., Haobijam, W.J. and Seram, D. (2025). Impacts of micro- irrigation technologies in Maharashtra : A review. Indian Journal of Agricultural Research. 59 (1):1-8. doi:10.18805/ IJARe.A-6269. Restrepo, G.C., Munoz, G. and Vermillion, D. (2007). Irrigation Management Transfer: Worldwide Efforts and Results. FAO Water Reports. 32: 2-4. Samad, M. and Vermillion, D. (1999). An assessment of the impact of participatory irrigation management in Sri Lanka. International Journal of Water Resources Development. 15(1-2): 219- 240. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/07900629949023 Senanayake, N., Mukherji, A. and Giordano, M. (2015). Re-visiting what we know about Irrigation Management Transfer: A review of the evidence. Agricultural Water Management. 149: 175-186. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.agwat.2014.11.004 Sinclair, J.A., Kumnerdpet, W. and Moyer, M.J. (2013). Learning Sustainable water practices through participatory irrigation management in Thailand. Natural Resources Forum . 37: 55-66. Sinha, P. (2014). Status of Participatory Irrigation Management (PIM) In India. National Convention of Presidents of Water User Associations organized by MoWR RD and GR.-India NPIM at Delhi. Sivamohan, M.V.K. and Sott, C.A. (1994). India: Irrigation management partnerships. Booklinks Corporation, Hyderabad. pp. 21-22. Uphoff, N. (1986). Improving International Irrigation Management with Farmer Participation. Getting the Process Right. Boulder, CO (USA) Westview Press. Uysal, K.Ö. and Altis, E. (2010). Assessing the performance of participatory irrigation management over time: A case study from Turkey. Agricultural Water Management. 97(7): 1017-1025. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.agwat.2010.02.007 Vermillion, D.L. (1991). The Turnover and Self Management of Irrigation Institutions in Developing Countries. International Irrigation Management Institute, Colombo. Yang, L., Ren, Y., Tang, Z. and Zhu, Y. (2021). Impact of institutional constraints on participatory irrigation management : The role of moral obligation. Irrigation and Drainage. 70(5): 1287-1297. http://doi.org/10.10002/ird.2602. Zhang, L., Heerink, N., Dries, L. and Shi, X. (2013). Water users associations and irrigation water productivity in northern China. Ecological Economics. 95: 128-136. Zhou, Q., Deng, X., Wu, F., Li, Z. and Song, W. (2017). Participatory irrigation management and irrigation water use efficiency in maize production: Evidence from Zhangye City, North- western China. Water. 9(11): 822. http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/w9110822.
EDITORIAL BOARD
Guided by Experienced Academic Leadership
Distinguished scholars and subject experts committed to editorial excellence, scientific integrity and rigorous peer review.