Indian Journal of Animal Research

Indian Journal of Animal Research cover
Volume 59 · Issue 12 · 2025/09/13

Meta-analysis of the Effects of Chinese Herbal Additives on the Production Performance, Immune Function and Meat Quality of Sheep

Zhina Du
Wu Sun
Xiayang Jin
Shike Ma
Yuhong Ma
310 Views

Submitted

2025/05/05

First Online

2025/09/13

doi

10.18805/IJAR.BF-2019

Cite article - Zhina Du, Wu Sun, Xiayang Jin, Shike Ma, Yuhong Ma. (2025). Meta-analysis of the Effects of Chinese Herbal Additives on the Production Performance, Immune Function and Meat Quality of Sheep. Indian Journal of Animal Research. 59(12): 2084–2091. doi: 10.18805/IJAR.BF-2019

Abstract

Background: This meta-analysis systematically evaluates the effects of Chinese herbal additives on production performance, immune function and meat quality in sheep to support their application in ruminant nutrition.

Methods: A total of 13 studies, comprising 37 controlled trials, were included in the analysis. The overall effect size was assessed by forest plots and meta-analysis was conducted to identify sources of heterogeneity, perform sensitivity analysis and evaluate publication bias by funnel plots.

Result: Dietary supplementation with Chinese herbal additives significantly increased average daily gain (ADG) and average daily feed intake (ADFI) ( P <0.05) and reduced the feed-to-gain ratio (F/G) ( P <0.05). Immunological analysis showed that serum IgA and IgM levels were elevated ( P <0.05). For meat quality parameters, the additives increased cooking yield and pH ( P <0.05) and decreased shear force ( P <0.05) with no significant effect on drip loss ( P >0.05). Funnel plot analysis revealed minimal publication bias and sensitivity analysis confirmed the robustness and reliability of the results. These findings suggested that Chinese herbal additives contributed to enhanced production performance, immune function and meat quality in sheep. Further research should validate these findings through more controlled feeding trials, while exploring the active ingredients and mechanisms of action of Chinese herbal additives.

References

  1. Bao, Y.L. and Liu, Y.Y. (2019). Effects of astragalus polysaccharides on growth performance and immune function of confined tibetan sheep. Chinese Journal of Animal Science . 55: 103-106. Chen, H., Guo, B., Yang, M., Luo, J., Hu, Y., Qu, M., Song, X. (2021). Response of growth performance, blood biochemistry indices and rumen bacterial diversity in lambs to diets containing supplemental probiotics and chinese medicine polysaccharides. Frontiers in Veterinary Science . 8: 2021. Cohen, J. (1988). Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Du, P.G. (2023). Formulation and application suggestions of chinese herbal medicinal fattening feed additives for meat sheep. Chinese Journal of Traditional Veterinary Science . 72: 67-69. Feng, N., Li, N.N., Liu, X.D., Liu, K.K., Ke, X.Q., Li, Y.X. (2024). Application advantages, existing problems and counter measures of chinese herbal feed additives in sheep breeding and production. Journal of Animal Science and Veterinary Medicine . 43: 105-111. Gao, Z.G., Di, N., Zhao, Z.X., Zhao, Y.E., Yong, Y.P. (2020). Effects of chinese herbal medicine additives on the meat quality and main umami factors of bamei mutton sheep. Feed Research . 43: 23-26. He, T. (2016). Functions and research directions of chinese herbal additives in animal husbandry production. Agriculture of Jilin. 88. Hedges, L. and Olkin, I. (1985). Statistical Methods for Meta-analysis, Academic Press. New York, NY, Google Scholar. Hern&aacute;ndez-Castellano, L.E., Moreno-Indias, I., Morales-delaNuez, A., S&aacute;nchez-Mac&iacute;as, D., Torres, A., Capote, J., Arg&uuml;ello, A., Castro, N. (2015). The effect of milk source on body weight and immune status of lambs. Livestock Science . 175: 70-76. Hou, L.Z., Duan, P.P., Yang, Y.X., Shah, A.M., Li, J.L., Xu, C.B., Guo, T.J. (2025). Effects of residual black wolfberry fruit on growth performance, rumen fermentation parameters, microflora and economic benefits of fattening sheep. Frontiers in Veterinary Science . 11: 1528126. Huang, X.Y. (2023). Research on the effects of chinese herbal additives on the fattening of lambs. Chinese Journal of Traditional Veterinary Science . pp: 10-12. Jin, Y.X., Fang, M.Y., Zhang, Q., Chen, Y. (2022). Effects of peanut meal replacing soybean meal and cotton meal on the growth performance, apparent digestibility, slaughter performance, meat quality and ruminal fermentation indexes of fattening sheep. Journal of Xinjiang Agricultural University . 45: 439-446. Karnani, M., R.K., D., T., S., Manju (2020). Effect of supplementation of herbal products as feed additive on rumen metabolites in marwari goats. Indian Journal of Animal Research . 55(2): 185-188. doi: 10.18805/ijar.B-3932 . Li, C.H., Dong, Y.L., Zhang, R.H., Wang, L., Shi, W.Y., Xu, T., Zhang, H.L. (2020). Effects of chinese herbal medicines on lipid metabolism and immunity function in laying hens. Indian Journal of Animal Research . 54(10): 1291-1295. doi: 10.18805/ijar.B-1261 . Li, J.K., Jin, X.J., Geng, K., Ren, F.L., Wang, X.H., Geng, C.Y., Jin, Y.H. (2024). Effects of supplementing chinese herbal medicine and active dry yeast preparations on diarrhea rate and rectal microflora diversity in yanbian cattle lactating calves. China Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Medicine . pp: 5317-5324. Li, N., Cheng, H.P., Liu, T.G., Chen, G.S., Sui, X.D., Zhu, C.Y., Han, X.M. (2021). Effects of astragalus membranaceus and radix isatidis on performance and immune indexes of huhan hybrid f1 sheep. China Feed . pp: 48-52. Li, Y.X., Guo, Z.X., Jiang, D., Chen, Y.K., Zhang, D.M., Zhang, W.H. (2025). Research progress of chinese medicine residues in aquaculture. Feed Industry . pp: 1-6. Liang, X., Yamazaki, K., Kamruzzaman, M., Bi, X., Panthee, A., Sano, H. (2013). Effects of chinese herbal medicine on plasma glucose, protein and energy metabolism in sheep. Journal of Animal Science and Biotechnology . 4(1): 51. Liao, Y.Q., Kang, Y.G., Chang, L.L. (2025). Effects of bacterial enzyme coordinated fermentation of medicinal residue on growth performance, immune indexes and serum biochemical indexes of lambs. China Feed . pp: 132-137. Liu, S.X., Zhang, C.L., Wang, H.J., Zhao, J.Y., Lu, W., He, Z.Q. (2023). Effects of radix astragali and radix isatidis on growth performance, immune and antioxidant functions of goats. Modern Journal of Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Medicine . pp: 33-37. Liu, X.D., Huang, Y., Liu, Y.F., Du, X.T. (2024). The effect of compound herbal additives on improving livestock and poultry production performance. Feed Industry . pp: 1-10. Ma, X., Niu, Y., Nan, S., Zhang, W. (2024). Effect of salvia sclarea l. extract on growth performance, antioxidant capacity and immune function in lambs. Frontiers in Veterinary Science . pp: 11-2024. Qu, Z.H., Han, Z.Q., Bai, Y., Xue, J., Cao, J.L., Ding, Z.X., Zhu, W.B., Zhao, J.H. (2024). Effects of different proportions of compound chinese herbal additives on growth performance, immunity and antioxidant capacity of qianan mutton sheep. Feed Industry . pp: 1-11. Shao, T.C., Huang, Y.E., Cui, X.M., Ji, Q.A., Song, H.H., Bao, G.L., Liu, Y.F. (2025). Effects of compound chinese herbal medicine on growth performance and intestinal health of rabbits. Chinese Journal of Animal Science . 61: 304-310. Shi, S.M. and Wang, F. (2024). Effects of eucommia ulmoides leaves extract on growth performance, serum biochemical and antioxidant indexes of hu sheep. China Feed. pp: 17-20. Tang, C.L., Wei, J.C., Teng, H.L., Li, F.Z., Huang, M. (2021). Research progress on anti-inflammatory activity of flavonoids and its mechanism. Chinese Archives of Traditional Chinese Medicine . 39: 154-159. Wang, C.H., Xin, X.Z., Pang, X. (2024). Research progress of traditional chinese medicine and west medicine combination treatment of colorectal cancer. Traditional Chinese Medicinal Research . 37: 84-88. Wang, X., Liu, J.G., Ma, Y.J., Wang, Y., Chen, L. (2019). Effects of compound chinese herbal medicine additives on slaughter performance, meat quality and rumen histomorphology of hu sheep. China Herbivore Science . 39: 22-25. Wang, X.D. (2016). Effects of chinese herbal medicine residue on nutritional quality of mutton. Journal of Animal Science and Veterinary Medicine . 35: 31-35. Wang, X.J., Ding, L.M., Wei, H.Y., Jiang, C.X., Yan, Q., Hu, C.S., Jia, G.X., Zhou, Y.Q., Henkin, Z., Degen, A.A. (2021). Astragalus membranaceus root supplementation improves average daily gain, rumen fermentation, serum immunity and antioxidant indices of tibetan sheep. Animal . 15: 100061. Wang, Y. (2023). Study on improving the quality of fattening mutton by chinese herbal medicine. Master. Wang, Z.H., He, Y.J., Wang, C.L., Zhang, Z.P., Zhong, H.M., Li, A.P., Li, Y.M. (2024). The effect of adding mulberry leaf flavonoids to feed on growth performance, muscle quality and serum biochemical indicators of meat sheep. China Feed . pp: 53-56. Wei, J.L. (2024). The influence of chinese herbal additives on the immunity of muscovy ducks. Chinese Animal Health . 26: 1131-1114. Wu, P.P. and He, S.J. (2023). Effects of guiqi yimu oral liquid fermented residue on growth properties, slaughter performance, serum biochemical and immune indexes of Hu sheep. Heilongjiang Animal Science and Veterinary Medicine . pp: 109-114. Xia, G.Y. (2022). Application of chinese herbal feed additives in mutton sheep production. Animals Breeding and Feed . 21: 60-62. Zhang, J., Xun, X.J., L&uuml;, Y., Wang, P.Y., Liu, D.X., Yang, T.T. (2024). Application of chinese herbal feed additives in livestock and poultry production. Northern Animal Husbandry . pp: 18. Zhang, L.C. (2023). Effects of fermented chinese herbal medicine on growth performance, blood biochemical, immune and antioxidant indexes of black goats. Hunan Journal of Animal Science and Veterinary Medicine . pp: 41-43. Zhang, N., Li, H., Jiang, C., Tu, Y., Diao, Q. (2016). Effects of lipopolysaccharide on the growth performance, nitrogen metabolism and immunity in preruminant calves. Indian Journal of Animal Research . 51(4): 717-721. doi: 10.18805/ ijar.v0iOF.6831 . Zhang, Q., Zhang, X.Q., Qu, H., Zhang, J.Z., Ma, L.F., Guo, Y., Jia, H., Tana, Wang, J.L. (2023). A meta analysis for the effects of feeding chinese herbal supplements on performance immune function and rumen fermentation in lambs. Chinese Journal of Grassland . 45: 118-129. Zhang, Y., Sun, W., Ma, S.K., Jin, X.Y., Ma, Y.H., Li, S.S., Wang, S.X. (2023). Meta-analysis of antimicrobial peptides feed additives on growth performance of finishing pigs. Modern Journal of Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Medicine . pp: 61-64. Zhang, Y.D., Zhao, C.Y., Guo, G.L., Wang, B.J. (2023). Effects of compound chinese herbal medicine on growth performance, slaughter performance, meat quality and immune function of mutton sheep. Journal of Domestic Animal Ecology . 44: 25-29. Zhang, Y.F., Nie, X.Y., Liu, K.X., Meng, C., Ao, C.W. (2024). Effects of probiotic-fermented herbal medicine preparation on growth performance of pigs and quality of pork. Journal of Domestic Animal Ecology . 45: 23-29. Zhao, J.Y., Yang, B., Luo, R.M., Zhang, H.Y., Su, C.X., Hu, Q.Q., Zhao, X.C. (2021). Metatranscriptomic analysis of microbial metabolic process in chilled tan sheep meat in different chilled storage periods. Food Science . 42: 111-119. Zhao, Z.W., Zhao, T., Yin, J., Ma, Q., Wang, J. (2020). Effects of chinese herbal medicine additives on growth, immune performance and meat quality of tan sheep. Chinese Journal of Animal Science . 56: 150-153. Zhou, Y., Wang, H.H., Liu, W.P., Xu, Y.Z. (2024). Effect of compound preparation of chinese herbal aqueous extract on ruminal fermentation and bacterial composition in tan lambs. China Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Medicine . pp: 4743-4754. Zhu, Y.F., Han, Y.S., Zhang, J.S., Li, W., Ding, D.L., Wang, Y.F., Yao, M.L., Li, Q.Y., Lin, X.W., Wang, H., Huang, M., Wang, H.B., Zhong, P. (2024). Research progress on the influence of chinese herbal feed additives on livestock and poultry meat quality. Heilongjiang Animal Science and Veterinary Medicine . pp: 17-21.
EDITORIAL BOARD

Guided by Experienced Academic Leadership

Distinguished scholars and subject experts committed to editorial excellence, scientific integrity and rigorous peer review.

View Full Board
Yashpal Singh Malik
Chief Editor

Yashpal Singh Malik

Deputy Director General (Agricultural Education)Indian Council of Agricultural Research, Headquarters, New Delhi , India

L.D. Singla
Associate chief editor

L.D. Singla

Professor and HeadAbhilashi University, Chachyot, Himachal Pradesh, India

Vilas G. Atkare
Editor

Vilas G. Atkare

DeanDr. Panjabrao Deshmukh Krishi Vidyapeeth, Akola, Krishi Nagar, Maharashtra, India

S. Maya
Editor

S. Maya

Associate Dean and Professor & HeadKerala Veterinary and Animal Sciences University, Mannuthy, Thrissur, Kerala, India