Legume Research

Legume Research cover
Volume 48 · Issue 10 · 2025/09/15

Silage Quality and Economic Efficiency Analysis of Hungarian Vetch ( Vicia pannonica Crantz) and Oats ( Avena sativa L.) Mixed at Different Ratios

Abdullah Eren
Erdal Karadenız
Aybüke Kaya
206 Views

Submitted

2022/06/29

First Online

2025/09/15

doi

10.18805/LRF-707

Cite article - Abdullah Eren, Erdal Karadenız, Aybüke Kaya. (2025). Silage Quality and Economic Efficiency Analysis of Hungarian Vetch ( Vicia pannonica Crantz) and Oats ( Avena sativa L.) Mixed at Different Ratios. Legume Research. 48(10): 1795–1803. doi: 10.18805/LRF-707

Abstract

Background: In this study, it was aimed to compare Hungarian vetch and oats mixed at different ratios not only in terms of silage quality but also in terms of their economic efficiency. “Anadolu Pembesi” Hungarian vetch variety and “Albatros” oat variety were used as plant material in the experiment.

Methods: Research was carried out during the winter of 2020-2021 on a farmer field in the Kızıltepe district of Mardin province (Turkiye). In the study, 100% Hungarian vetch, 100% oat, 70% Hungarian vetch + 30% oat, 60% Hungarian vetch + 40% oat, 50% Hungarian vetch + 50% oat, 30% Hungarian vetch + 70% oat silages were tested. Besides silage quality, input-cost analysis and comparison in terms of economic efficiency were also made in the study.

Result: Ph value, dry matter, crude protein ratio, acid detergent insoluble fiber, neutral detergent insoluble fiber, digestible dry matter, dry matter consumption, relative feed value and lactic acid ratio varied between 3.88-4.11; 25.02-29.24%; 12.17-19.64%; 31.34-40.24%; 45.27-55.14%; 57.55-64.49%; 2.18-2.65%; 97.15-132.58 and 1.82%-2.38%, respectively. When all the features are evaulated together, 70% Hungarian vetch + 30% oat silage mixture was recommended due to high crude protein ratio, high relative feed value and lactic acid ratio in between low acid detergent insoluble fiber and neutral detergent insoluble fiber ratios. On the other hand, 50% HVS + 50% OS and 60% HVS + 40% OS mixtures stand out as balanced options in terms of both economic gain and quality. This ratio represents the economic optimum point in roughage production and offers an important alternative in the creation of sustainable feed resources.

References

  1. Acosta Aragón, Y., Jatkauskas, J. and Vrotniakienė, V. (2012). The effect of a silage inoculant on silage quality, aerobic stability and meat production on farm scale. International Scholarly Research Notices . 2012(1): 345927. Açıkgöz, E. (1995). Forage Crops (2 nd ed.). Uludağ University, Faculty of Agriculture, Press No: 7-025-0210, Bursa. 456 p. Açıkgöz, E. (2001). Forage crops. Uludag University Faculty of Agriculture Publications, No: 166. Agricultural Economics Research Institute, Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry (Republic of Türkiye) (TEAE). (2024). Report on forage crop production costs in Turkey. https://www.teae. gov.tr/yem-bitkileri-2024 [Access date: 05.01.2024]. Alcicek, A. and Ozkan, K. (1997). A Study on determination of silage quality by chemical and physical analysis in the fermantated silage. Turkey I. Congress of silage. 19 September 1997. Bursa, pp. 241-246. Altınok, S. (2002). A study on the determination of silage quality characteristics of barley, Hungarian vetch and hairy vetch mixed at different ratios. Journal of Agricultural Sciences . 8(3): 232-237. Anonymous, (1993). Bestimmung des pH-Wertes. In: Die chemischen Untersuchungen von Futtermitteln. Teil 18 Silage. Abschnit 18.1 Bestimmung des pH-Wertes. Methodenbuch Bd. III., VDLUFAV Verlag, Darmstadt. Anonymous, (2015a). Access link: http://www.amasyadsyb.org/besleme/ lif.html [Access date: 05.11.2018]. Anonymous, (2015b). Access link: http://www.amasyadsyb.org/besleme/ lif.html [Access date: 05.11.2018]. Arslan, M., Erdurmuþ, C., Öten, M., Aydınoğlu, B. and Çakmakçı, S. (2017). Quality charecteristics of sorghum and some plants silages mixed at different rates. Journal of Tekirdag Agricultural Faculty . 14(02): 34-41. Avci, M. and Koç, A. (2021). Effect of cereals and legumes on protein and energy balance in mixed silages. Turkish Journal of Agriculture and Natural Sciences . 8(1): 45-52. Avellaneda, J.H., Pinos-Rodríguez, J.M., González, S.S., Bárcena, R., Hernández, A., Cobos, M. and Montañez, O. (2009). Effects of exogenous fibrolytic enzymes on ruminal fermentation and digestion of Guinea grass hay. Animal Feed Science and Technology . 149(1-2): 70-77. Avila, C.L.S. and Carvalho, B.F. (2019) Silage fermentation - updates focusing on the performance of microorganisms. Journal Appl Microbiol . 128(4): 966-984. Aydın, A., Tan, M. and Yüksel, S. (2015). Silage quality and nutritional values of mixed forage crops. Journal of Feed Science and Technology . 2(2): 88-94. Aydın, İ., Uzun, F. and Algan, D. (2015). Yield and nutritive values of some wild annual medic species collected from different geographical location. Anadolu Journal of Agricultural Sciences . 30(3): 275-280. Aykan, Y. and Saruhan, V. (2018). Determination of silage quality features of field Pea ( Pisum sativum L.) and barley ( Hordeum vulgare L.) mixtures ensiling at different rates. Dicle University Faculty of Veterinary Medicine Journal. 11(2): 64-70. Bengisu, G. (2019). A study on the silage properties of hungarian vetch ( Vicia pannonica Crantz.) and barley ( Hordeum vulgare L.) grass mixtures in different rates. Legume Research . 42(5): 680-683. doi: 10.18805/LR-494 . Boz, İ. and Akbay, C. (2005). Attitudes of agricultural producers towards innovations: The GAP-Şanlıurfa case. Journal of Agricultural Economics . 11(2): 17-25. Bulgurlu, Ş. and Ergül, M. (1978). Physical, chemical and biological analysis methods of feeds. Ege University Press, Publication No: 127, İzmir. pp. 176. Carr, P.M., Horsley, R.D. and Poland, W.W. (2004). Barley, oat and cereal-pea mixtures as dryland forages in the northern Great Plains. Agronomy Journal . 96(3): 677-684. Carvalho, B.F., Sales, G.F.C., Schwan, R.F. and Ávila, C.L.S. (2021). Criteria for lactic acid bacteria screening to enhance silage quality. Journal of Applied Microbiology . 130(2): 341-355. Demirel, M., Cengiz, F., Erdoğan, S. and Çelik, S. (2003). A study on silage quality and rumen degradability of mixed silages containing different levels of sudangrass and hungarian vetch. Turkish Journal of Veterinary and Animal Sciences . 27(4): 853-859. Demirel, R., Saruhan, V., Baran, M.S. andiç, N. and Demirel, D.Ş. (2010). Determination of different ratios of Trifolium repens and Hordeum vulgare mixtures on silage quality. Yüzüncü Yıl University Journal of Agricultural Sciences . 20(1): 26-31. Dewhurst, R. (2013). Milk production from silage: Comparison of grass, legume and maize silages and their mixtures. Agricultural and Food Science . 22(1): 57-69. Dewhurst, R.J., Delaby, L., Moloney, A., Boland, T. and Lewis, E. (2009). Nutritive value of forage legumes used for grazing and silage. Irish Journal of Agricultural and Food Research . 48(2): 167-187. Dewhurst, R.J., Scollan, N.D., Lee, M.R.F., Ougham, H.J. and Humphreys, M.O. (2009). Forage breeding and management to increase the beneficial fatty acid content of ruminant products. Proceedings of the Nutrition Society . 62(2): 329-336. Duru, M., Demirtaş, Z. and Altın, M. (2019). Roughage production potential and evaluation opportunities in Turkey. Journal of Agricultural Economics Research . 25(2): 103-112. Ergün, A., Tuncer, Ş.D., Çolpan, İ., Yalçın, S., Yıldız, G., Küçükersan, M.K., Küçükersan, S., Şehu, A. and Saçaklı, P. (2013). Feeds, feed hygiene and technology. Extended 5 th edition, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Ankara University, Ankara. Erkuş, A., Bülbül, M., Kıral, T., Alemdar, T. And Demirci, R. (2013). Agricultural economics. Ankara: Atatürk University Faculty of Agriculture Publications. Eskandari, H., Ghanbari, A. and Javanmard, A. (2009). Intercropping of cereals and legumes for forage production. Notulae Scientia Biologicae . 1(1): 07-13. Fabiszewska, A.U., Zielińska, K.J. and Wróbel, B. (2019). Trends in designing microbial silage quality by biotechnological methods using lactic acid bacteria inoculants: A minireview. World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology . 35(5): 1-8. FAO. (2017). The future of food and agriculture: Trends and challenges. Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Fayetörbay, D., Dumlu, G.Z. and Tan, M. (2011). Determination of silage values of forage pea-wheat and forage peameadow grass mixtures. IX. Turkish Field Crops Congress, 12-15 September 2011, Bursa-Türkiye. Filya, İ. (2002). The effects of lactic acid bacterial inoculants on the fermentation, aerobic stability and in situ rumen degradability characteristics of maize and sorghum silages. Turkish Journal of Veterinary and Animal Sciences . 26(4): 815-823 Güre, E. (2016). An investigation on usage possibilities of sweet sorghum ( Sorghum Bicolor (L.) Moench Var. Saccharatum) and black eyed-pea ( Vigna Unguiculata (L.) Walp.) mixture for silage. (M.Sc). Ege University Institute of Natural and Applied Science, İzmir. Hazell, P.B.R. and Norton, R.D. (1986). Mathematical programming for economic analysis in agriculture. New York: Macmillan Publishing Company. Ibrahim, M., Ayub, M., Maqbool, M.M., Nadeem, S.M., ul Haq, T., Hussain, S. and Lauriault, L.M. (2014). Forage yield components of irrigated maize-legume mixtures at varied seed ratios. Field Crops Research . 169: 140-144. Kacar, B. and Katkat, A.V. (2010). Fertilizers and fertilization techniques. Nobel Publishing. Kalaycı, M. (2005). Examples of Jump usage and variance analysis models for agricultural research. Anatolian Agricultural Research Institute Publications, Publication (21). pp. 296. Kandemir, N., Koç, A. and Tahtacıoğlu, L. (2010). The current situation and development opportunities of forage crop production in Turkey. Proceedings of the 7 th Field Crops Congress of Turkey. (2): 899-902. Kavut, Y.T., Kaplan, M. and Gül, M. (2014). Comparison of silage quality and crude protein content in different legume-cereal mixtures. Journal of Field Crops Central Research Institute . 23(1): 41-48. Khafipour, E., Li, S., Plaizier, J.C. and Krause, D.O. (2009). Rumen microbiome composition determined using two nutritional models of subacute ruminal acidosis. Applied and Environmental Microbiology . 75(22): 7115-7124. Kilic, A. (1986). Silo feed teaching, learning and application suggestions. Bilgehan Publishing House, İzmir, pp. 264. Koç, A. and Gül, M. (2018). Forage crop cultivation and the effect- iveness of support policies in Turkey. Turkish Journal of Agriculture and Natural Sciences . 5(2): 153-160. Morrison, J.A. (2003). Hay and pasture management, Chapter 8. Extension educator, crop systems rockford extension center. http:// iah. aces.uiuc.edu/pdf/Agronomy _HB/ 08chapter. Piltz, J., Rodham, C., Walker, J., Matthews, P., Hackney, B. and Wilkins, J. (2011). Cereal based forage crops for hay and silage production. In Annual Grasslands Conference: Grassland Farmers-Opportunýtýes, Threats and Realıtıe. The Grassland Society of NSW Inc. (pp. 81-87) Redfearn, D., Zhang, H. and Caddel, J. (2012). Forage quality Inter- pretations. Oklahoma Cooperative Extension Service. PSS-2117, p:4, Available from URL: http://pss.okstate. edu/publications/publications-masterlist/copy_of_ publications/ forages/PSS-2117web.pdf [Access date: 01.01.2019]. Sadeghpour, A., Jahanzad, E., Esmaeili, A., Hosseini, M.B. and Hashemi, M. (2013). Forage yield, quality and economic benefit of intercropped barley and annual medic in semi-arid conditions: Additive series. Field Crops Research . 148: 43-48. Seydosoglu, S. (2019). Effects of different mixture ratios of grass pea ( Lathyrus sativus L.) and barley ( Hordeum vulgare ) on quality of silage. Legume Research . 42(5): 666-670. doi: 10.18805/LR-468 . Sohail, S., Ansar, M., Skalicky, M., Wasaya, A., Soufan, W., Ahmad Yasir, T and EL Sabagh, A. (2021). Influence of tillage systems and cereals-legume mixture on fodder yield, quality and net returns under rainfed conditions. Sustainability . 13(4): 2172. TAGEM (General Directorate of Agricultural Research and Policies). (2022). Report on forage crop production potential. https:// www.tagem.gov.tr [Access date: 18.05.2022]. Tekce, E. and Gül, M. (2014). The Importance of NDF and ADF in Ruminant Nutrition. Atatürk University Journal of Veterinary Sciences . 9(1): 63-73. TOB, (Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry (Republic of Türkiye). (2024a). Fertilizer and seed price bulletin. https://www. tarimorman.gov.tr [Access date: 15.10.2024]. TOB, (Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry (Republic of Türkiye). (2024b). Communiqué and implementation guide on forage crop subsidies. https://www.tarimorman.gov.tr [Access date: 15.10.2024]. TUIK (Turkish Statistical Institute). (2021). https://biruni.tuik.gov.tr/medas/ ?kn=92andlocale=tr [Access date: 12.10.2022]. Yang, W.Z. and Beauchemin, K.A. (2009). Increasing physically effective fiber content of dairy cow diets through forage proportion versus forage chop length: Chewing and ruminal pH. Journal of Dairy Science . 92(4): 1603-1615. Yılmaz, S., Mut, H. and Acar, Z. (2019). The importance of legume- cereal mixtures in closing the roughage deficit. Turkish Journal of Agriculture and Natural Sciences . 6(3): 403-410.
EDITORIAL BOARD

Guided by Experienced Academic Leadership

Distinguished scholars and subject experts committed to editorial excellence, scientific integrity and rigorous peer review.

View Full Board
Kadambot Siddique
Chief Editor

Kadambot Siddique

DirectorThe UWA Institute of Agriculture, The University of Western Australia, AUSTRALIA

Pei Xu
Associate chief editor

Pei Xu

DeanChina Jiliang University, CHINA

Satpal Singh Bisht
Editor

Satpal Singh Bisht

Vice ChancellorS.S.J.University Almora, Uttarakhand, INDIA

H.K. Dikshit
Editor

H.K. Dikshit

Principal Scientist Indian Agricultural Research Institute, New Delhi, INDIA